The Wikipedia editing story that won’t die

Eric Newton
6 min readJul 4, 2023

It’s been 18 years, and the anonymous editors of Wikipedia, as wonderful as they can be, are still doing me wrong.

As of this morning, Wikipedia co-founder Jimmy Wales was still getting credit for doing what I actually did back in the day, which was to remove a horrific hoax from the platform.

So when the podcast company Novel called to interview me for a story on BBC Radio 4 that aired today, I said sure. One more try.

Is it ever too late to run a correction?

Here, hopefully for the last time, is the story — tech journalist Lara Lewington’s thoughtful report plus my own effort.

Wikipedia is so important these days, I hope they will reconsider why in the digital age its editors must remain anonymous.

___

What became known as the Seigenthaler Incident started back in 2005, when an unfunny joker in Nashville decided to shock a coworker by planting a false article on Wikipedia about iconic journalist John Seigenthaler Sr.

John was a great man, a hero to many of us. He defined the term “distinguished journalist.” He rose from cub reporter to chairman emeritus of the Nashville Tennessean as a voice of reality and reason in the south during the civil rights era. He was a top-tier investigative…

--

--

Eric Newton

I chased the future of news in newsrooms, boardrooms and classrooms. Now I write about life, news, nonprofits, digital media, philanthropy and education. .